Institute of Product Leadership
Close this search box.

Why Is It So Hard to Get a Job as a Product Manager?

The role of a Product Manager (PM) is often regarded as one of the most coveted positions in the tech industry and beyond. PMs are responsible for shaping the product vision, guiding development teams, and ensuring that the final product meets customer needs. However, breaking into this field can be a daunting challenge. In this blog, we’ll delve deep into the hurdles aspiring Product Managers face and provide detailed solutions to overcome them. We’ll focus on three main problems and offer practical advice for navigating the competitive landscape of product management.

Key Takeaways:

  • Product Manager roles vary widely, so research a company’s culture and values, network with current PMs, and develop a diverse skill set to tailor your application effectively.
  • Here we will also delve into why PMs must consider applying to startups, which often have less formal recruitment processes.
  • This blog also explores why to seek internal transitions, look for roles with PM-like responsibilities, and gain practical experience.

Problem 1: The Gray Area of Product

One of the biggest challenges faced by aspiring Product Managers is the ambiguous nature of the role. Unlike traditional professions like law or medicine, there is no universally accepted set of qualifications or certifications that define a PM’s credentials. This leads to a “gray area” where job requirements can vary significantly from one company to another.

Solution: Read Between the Lines

To navigate this ambiguity, aspiring PMs should become skilled at reading between the lines of job postings, which include:

1. Understand the Company’s Culture

Research the company’s culture and values to gauge what they might value in a PM. 

For example, a startup might prioritize adaptability and hands-on experience, while a larger corporation may value strategic thinking and leadership. The deeper your understanding of a company’s culture, the better you can tailor your application to align with their values.

2. Talk to Current PMs

Networking is not just about making connections; it’s about gaining valuable insights. Reach out to current PMs and ask about their backgrounds and experiences. This can give you a wealth of information about what the company values in its Product Managers and what product management skills and experiences are essential for success in their specific environment.

3. Build a Diverse Skill Set

Since the role is diverse, focus on developing a broad skill set that includes project management, data analysis, user research, and strategic thinking. This will not only make you a more attractive candidate but also provide you with a solid foundation for success once you land the job. 

Let’s delve deeper into each of these skills:

a. Project Management

Product Managers are often referred to as “mini-CEOs” because they are responsible for the entire product development process. Hence to excel in this role, aspiring PMs should develop strong project management skills. You might consider taking courses or certifications in project management methodologies such as Agile or Scrum.

b. Data Analysis

Data is at the heart of decision-making in product management. You’ll need to analyze user data, market trends, and product metrics to make informed decisions and familiarize yourself with data analysis tools like Excel, SQL, or data visualization platforms like Tableau.

c. User Research

Understanding your target audience is essential for building successful products. Further also learn about user research techniques, including user interviews, surveys, and usability testing to create products that truly meet customer needs.

d. Strategic Thinking

Product Managers must think strategically to set a long-term vision for their products. Hence read books and articles on strategic planning and business strategy to develop this critical skill.

Problem 2: The Recruitment Process

The recruitment process for Product Manager positions can be grueling and competitive. Often, it involves multiple rounds of interviews, case studies, and presentations. Many aspiring PMs find it challenging to even get their foot in the door due to this demanding process.

Solution: Change up your process

Consider applying to smaller startups or companies where the recruitment process may be less formal and competitive. Startups often value versatility and hands-on experience, making it easier for newcomers to break in. Here’s a more detailed exploration of this solution:

1. The Benefits of Joining a Startup

Startups can provide a unique and valuable learning experience for aspiring PMs. In smaller companies, you’ll likely have more responsibilities and opportunities to work on a variety of projects. This hands-on experience can help you build a strong foundation for a career in product lifecycle management.

2. Overcoming Challenges in Startups

While startups offer great potential, they also come with challenges. Be prepared to adapt quickly, wear multiple hats, and work in a dynamic and sometimes chaotic environment. These challenges can be a valuable part of your learning journey as a Product Manager.

3. Get Networking

Networking is one of the most powerful product management tools for advancing your career in the tech industry. Building relationships with current PMs can lead to valuable referrals and job opportunities. 

Let’s dive deeper into the world of networking:

a. The Importance of Networking

In the tech industry, who you know can be just as important as what you know. Networking allows you to tap into hidden job opportunities, gain insights from experienced professionals, and stay updated on industry trends.

b. How to Network Effectively

Effective networking goes beyond just collecting business cards. Attend industry events, conferences, and meetups to connect with professionals in your field. Engage in online communities, such as LinkedIn groups, to participate in discussions and showcase your expertise.

c. Informational Interviews

Consider conducting informational interviews with PMs in your network. These informal conversations can provide valuable insights into the industry, the companies you’re interested in, and the skills you should prioritize developing.

d. Prepare for Interviews

The interview process for Product Manager roles can be intense, often including behavioral questions, case studies, and presentations. Here’s a more comprehensive look at how to prepare effectively:

e. Behavioral Questions

Prepare answers to common behavioral questions, such as “Tell me about a time when you had to make a difficult decision” or “Describe a situation where you had to manage a challenging team member.” Use the STAR (Situation, Task, Action, Result) method to structure your responses.

f. Case Studies

Many PM interviews include case study questions that assess your problem-solving and analytical skills. Practice solving case studies by working through examples from books, online resources, or with a study group.

g. Presentations

Some interviews may require you to present a product strategy or idea. Develop your presentation skills by creating and delivering practice presentations. Seek feedback from peers or mentors to improve your presentation style.

h. Mock Interviews

Consider participating in mock interviews to simulate the interview experience. This can help you become more comfortable with the format and receive constructive feedback.

Problem 3: The Educational Gap

Many aspiring Product Managers face the “Catch-22” situation: you need experience to get a job, but you need a job to gain experience. This educational gap can be disheartening for those trying to break into the field.

Solution: Overcoming the Educational Gap

1. “Leaving the Devil You Know for the Devil You Don’t”

If you are currently working in a different role within a company, consider seeking internal opportunities to transition into a Product Manager role. Your existing knowledge of the company’s products and processes can be a valuable asset. Let’s explore this further:

a. Internal Transitions

Transitioning internally is often easier than securing an external PM position because your current employer is already familiar with your work ethic and potential. Express your interest in transitioning to a PM role with your supervisor or HR department.

b. Demonstrating Value

Highlight how your current role has equipped you with skills and knowledge that are transferable to product and brand management. Emphasize your ability to collaborate with cross-functional teams, understand customer needs, and analyze data.

2. “PM Job Postings That Aren’t PM”

Sometimes, positions that are not explicitly labeled as Product Manager roles may involve PM-like responsibilities. Look for roles such as project coordinator, business analyst, or product analyst, which can serve as stepping stones to a PM career. Here’s a deeper exploration of this solution:

a. Project Coordinator

Roles like project coordinator often involve aspects of project management and coordination. You may be responsible for scheduling, tracking progress, and ensuring deliverables are met. These skills are highly transferable to a Product Manager role, where you’ll be managing product development projects.

b. Business Analyst

Business analysts gather and analyze data to help organizations make informed decisions. This role requires skills in data analysis and understanding business needs, both of which are crucial in product management. Transitioning from a business analyst role to a PM position can be a natural progression.

c. Product Analyst

Product analysts focus on understanding user behavior and product performance. They play a critical role in shaping product strategies. Gaining experience as a product analyst can provide valuable insights and skills that can be leveraged in a Product Manager role.

3. “You Need Experience to Get Experience”

Gaining practical experience is crucial for landing a PM job, but it can be challenging for newcomers. Here are more comprehensive strategies to acquire the experience you need:

a. Freelance Projects

Consider taking on freelance projects related to product management. Websites like Upwork and Freelancer offer opportunities to work on small product-related tasks or collaborate with startups on short-term projects.

b. Volunteering for Non-Profit Organizations

Non-profit organizations often need help with project management and technology-related initiatives. Volunteering your time and skills for a cause you’re passionate about can provide you with practical experience and demonstrate your commitment to the field.

c. Personal Projects

Initiate personal projects that allow you to practice product management. Create your own apps or products, document your process, and share the results on platforms like Medium or GitHub. This not only builds your portfolio but also showcases your dedication to the field.

4. “People Don’t Know How to Look for Jobs”

Finding the right job opportunities can be challenging, but with a well-thought-out job search strategy, you can increase your chances of success. Here’s a more comprehensive approach to job searching:

a. Tailor Your Resume and Cover Letter

Customize your resume and cover letter for each application. Highlight relevant skills, experiences, and achievements that align with the specific job description. Use keywords from the job posting to improve your chances of passing automated applicant tracking systems.

b. Use Multiple Job Search Channels

Don’t rely solely on job boards. Leverage a variety of job search channels, including company websites, LinkedIn, professional associations, and referrals. The more diverse your sources, the greater your chances of finding hidden job opportunities.

c. Career Coach or Mentor

Consider working with a career coach or mentor who specializes in product management. They can provide guidance, review your resume and application materials, and help you navigate the job search process effectively.

d. Online Presence

Invest in building a strong online presence. Create a professional LinkedIn profile that showcases your skills and experiences. Share relevant articles, insights, and updates to demonstrate your expertise in the field.

5. “Proving That You Have the Skills”

Proving your skills as an aspiring Product Manager requires more than just words; you need tangible evidence of your capabilities. Here are detailed ways to demonstrate your skills:

a. Create a Personal Website or Portfolio

Build a personal website or portfolio showcasing your product management work. Include case studies, projects, and any relevant contributions to open-source initiatives. This online portfolio serves as tangible proof of your abilities and can impress potential employers.

b. Share Case Studies

Write detailed case studies about your product management experiences. These should include problem statements, your approach, the steps you took, and the outcomes achieved. Share these case studies on platforms like Medium or LinkedIn to showcase your thought process and results.

c. Side Projects

Initiate side projects related to product management. Develop your own apps, tools, or products, and document the entire process. Share these projects on platforms like GitHub or your personal website to demonstrate your skills in action.

d. Certifications

Consider pursuing relevant certifications, such as the International Certificate in Product Management from the Institute of Product Leadership. These certifications can provide structured learning, validation of your skills, and a competitive edge in the job market.

Is There Hope for Aspiring Product Managers?

Absolutely! While breaking into the field of Product Management can be challenging, it is certainly achievable with determination, the right strategy, and continuous learning. By addressing the issues of ambiguity in the role, refining your job search process, and bridging the educational gap, you can position yourself as a strong candidate in this competitive field.

Moreover, pursuing relevant certifications, such as the International Certificate in Product Management from the Institute of Product Leadership, can significantly enhance your prospects. These programs offer comprehensive training, hands-on experience, and access to a network of industry professionals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Getting a Product Manager job can be tough due to the ambiguous nature of the role, varying job requirements across companies, and the need for a diverse skill set.

You can tailor your application effectively by researching a company’s culture and values, networking with current Product Managers to gain insights, and developing a diverse skill set that includes project management, data analysis, user research, and strategic thinking.

You should consider applying to startups where recruitment processes may be less formal and which value versatility and hands-on experience.

Overcoming the educational gap can be achieved through internal transitions within your current company, looking for roles with PM-like responsibilities, and gaining experience through freelance work, volunteering, personal projects, and certifications.

You can find the right PM job by tailoring your resume and cover letter for each application, using multiple job search channels, considering working with a career coach or mentor, and building a strong online presence.

Explore Our Programs

Institute of Product Leadership is Asia’s First Business School providing accredited degree programs and certification courses exclusively in Product Management, Strategy, and Leadership.

Talk to a counselor today and embark on your journey towards becoming an exceptional product manager.

Whether you’re seeking advice on career paths, looking to enhance your skills, or facing challenges in your current role, our counselors are ready to provide valuable insights and actionable strategies.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *